All use cases

ReviewerThree assists reviewers and editors with manuscript screening: summarising key arguments and weaknesses, identifying methodological gaps, automated ethical compliance checks, consistency scoring and writing tips.

ReviewerZero detects integrity issues before publication: image duplication, statistical inconsistencies, missing citations and figure accessibility problems, serving publishers, researchers, institutions and reviewers.

ReviewFlow, from Sun et al., is a research prototype supporting novice peer reviewers: contextual guidance while reading, help critiquing submissions, and synthesis of notes into structured reviews.

ReviewRobot, from Wang et al. (2020), generates explainable paper reviews by building knowledge graphs from the target paper and related work, producing structured review comments with reasons attached.

Scalene is Chris Leonard’s newsletter on AI and peer review — tracking the possibility that AI assists or outright generates reviews, against the backdrop of a review system that increasingly can’t staff itself.